On alvin plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. Wcrl is no exception, so reading it requires some patience, and a modest toleration for logical formalism, but patience and toleration are rewarded by a richly argued narrative. Evolutionary argument against naturalism hereafter eaan was refined in the. This the leading textbook on evolutionary psychology. The evolutionary genetics of personalityy psychology today. This work also contains plantingas notes on his speech regarding a dozen or so arguments for god. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of. It might be true, but it cannot be rational to affirm it as such.
The blackwell companion to naturalism wiley online books. Plantinga is an analytic philosopher whose works are filled with careful, sustained arguments. Naturalism defeated essays on plantingas evolutionary. An introduction to the thought of alvin plantinga crossway. Plantinga s argument has been criticized in detail from the viewpoints of natural sciences and philosophy of science.
One of todays most controversial and heated issues is whether or not the conflict between science and religion can be reconciled. Apr 25, 2017 alvin plantinga was born in ann arbor, michigan. This discussion ranges broadly across recent scientific findings in areas such as paleoanthropology, primate studies, evolutionary psychology, early brain development, and cultural transmission. Grabo1 1department of experimental and applied psychology, vrije universiteit amsterdam, and 2institute for cognitive and evolutionary anthropology, university of oxford abstract many psychological studies have shown that facial appearance matters in the people we select as leaders. Plantinga basically uses a possible world analysis. Plantinga s argument is intended to show that evolutionary naturalism cannot be rationally affirmed. Plantinga repeats the argument in his 2011 book where the conflict really lies.
Pdf evolutionary psychology download full pdf book. Dennett and alvin plantinga expand upon the arguments that they presented in an exciting live debate held at the 2009 american philosophical association central division conference. Dennett and alvin plantinga expand upon the arguments that they presented in an exciting live debate held at the 2009 american philosophical association central division. The evolutionary psychology of emotions and behavior. Plantinga examines where this conflict is supposed to exist evolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religion as well as claims by dan dennett, richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist. Essays on alvin plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism, plantinga restates his original argument, followed by eleven essays critical or not very critical in varying degrees, and capped by plantingas response. Download this volume collects thirteen papers by hilary kornblith on the theme of naturalistic epistemology. As the son of a philosophy and psychology professor, plantinga evidenced a knack for and interest in philosophy early on. Alvin carl plantinga born 1932 is an american analytic philosopher who works primarily in the fields of philosophy of religion, epistemology particularly on issues involving epistemic justification, and logic. Jan 28, 2016 kelly james clark is a senior research fellow at the kaufman interfaith institute of grand valley state university in grand rapids, michigan.
It seeks to identify which human psychological traits are evolved adaptations that is, the functional products of natural selection or sexual selection in human evolution. Given that naturalism is at least a quasireligion, there is indeed a sciencereligion conflict, all right, but it is not between science and theistic religion. Plantinga s modal ontological argument includes many of the aspects of anselms original argument but includes various additions and changes. Evolutionary psychology is a theoretical approach in the social and natural sciences that examines psychological structure from a modern evolutionary perspective. Because these disciplines are so broadly construed, the christian who is interested in apparent conflicts between science and biblical christianity will likely be somewhat disappointed in plantingas treatment. Evolutionary argument against naturalism oxford scholarship. An enlightening discussion that will motivate students to think critically, the book opens with plantingas assertion that christianity is compatible with evolutionary theory because christians believe that god created the living world, and it is entirely possible that god. The book examines where this conflict is supposed to existevolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religionas well as claims by dan dennett, richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist. Miller4 1humboldt university, berlin, germany 2international max. That belief, thereforethe conjunction of naturalism and evolutionis one that.
Massimo pigliucci, a philosopher at the city university of new york. Ebook god and other minds as pdf download portable document. Alvin plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. Raised in the christian reformed church, he has theological roots in the dutch reformed tradition. In fact the proportion of insult, ridicule, mockery, spleen, and vitriol is astounding.
These papers present kornbliths own version of a naturalistic epistemology, together with critical discussion of alternative approaches, including work on foundationalism, the coherence theory of justification, internalism and externalism, social epistemology, the role of intuitions in. The evolutionary argument against naturalism eaan is a philosophical argument asserting a problem with believing both evolution and philosophical naturalism simultaneously. If you want to have the broadest overview of evolutionary psychology, this your book. This chapter, while heavy, is an extremely rewarding read, particularly for people with interests in evolutionary psychology, philosophy of religion, or both. Plantingas control of language is unmatched, his reasoning and writing of the utmost quality and clarity. Why the evidence of evolution reveals a universe without design. Alvin plantinga contemporary philosophy in focus deane. Plantingas book is a semipopular treatment of the conflicts, real or perceived, between science and religion, broadly construed. Books about evolutionary psychology written for a general audience. Pdf a naturalistic epistemology download ebook for free. Evolutionary argument against naturalism wikipedia. The god delusion, however, contains little science. Alvin plantinga on evolutionary psychology and christian.
Here is how he formulates the argument in his recent where the conflict really lies oxford university press, 2011, pp. Historical and contemporary discussions 2014, the story of ethics. During this period plantingas work centers on a defense of the rationality of religious belief in the book god and other minds, general metaphysics and philosophy of religion in the nature of necessity, and the longstanding conundrum of the existence of evil in a world where god is omnipotent in the nature of. As the above quotation suggests, one shouldnt look to this book for evenhanded and thoughtful commentary. May 10, 20 the christian philosopher alvin plantinga has tried to make the argument that evolution combined with naturalism would lead us to believe that evolution would favor false beliefs over accurate beliefs and that if naturalism were true, we wouldnt expect our cognitive faculties to have evolved to accurately comprehend reality. Score a book s total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book. Religion enables us to ignore nothingness and get on with the jobs of life. He has published more than twenty books, including religion and the sciences of origins.
Richard dawkins, and philip kitcher that evolution and theistic belief cannot coexist. While these subjects are complex, the story is told here in a conversational style that is engaging, jargon free, and accessible to all readers. The evolutionary argument against naturalism eaan is a philosophical argument asserting a. Plantingas argument has been criticized in detail from the viewpoints of natural sciences and philosophy of science.
To do so, he draws examples from evolutionary psychology in particular. Michelle sugiyama has published several articles that use darwinian anthro pology and evolutionary psychology to illuminate important issues in literary theory and especially in narrative. Available on kindle ebook and can be read on any device with the free. This is, incidentally, the most popular argument from plantinga and from this book as a whole, the socalled evolutionary argument against naturalism eaan wikipedia has an article on it. Albeit designed as a textbook for graduate students, its equally good for the general public. Plantingas modal ontological argument includes many of the aspects of anselms original argument but includes various additions and changes. From 1963 to 1982, plantinga taught at calvin college before accepting an appointment as the john a. Within the field of evolutionary science, critics admit that organisms can be. On plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism. Evolutionary psychology is an approach that views human nature as the product of a universal set of evolved psychological adaptations to recurring problems in the ancestral environment. Plantinga s control of language is unmatched, his reasoning and writing of the utmost quality and clarity.
Evolutionary argument against naturalism in plantinga s evolutionary argument against naturalism eaan for short12, he attempts to show that to combine naturalism and evolution is selfdefeating, because, under these assumptions, the probability that humans have reliable cognitive faculties is low or inscrutable. Science, religion, and naturalism article pdf available in minds and machines 243. His theme in this short book is that the conflict between science and theistic. Jul 15, 20 rationally speaking is a blog maintained by prof. Jan 23, 2020 a clearer reading would be, the probability of reliable cognitive faculties given naturalism and evolution, is low. This chapter argues that there is superficial conflict but deep concord between science and theistic belief, and superficial concord and deep conflict between science and naturalism. The argument was first proposed by alvin plantinga in 1993 and raises issues of interest to epistemologists, philosophers of mind, evolutionary biologists, and. Article pdf available in integrative and comparative biology 491. Applications of evolutionary psychology to other disciplines. Affective influences on social cognition and behavior. An enlightening discussion that will motivate students to think critically, the book. Evolutionary,psychology, the,new,science,of,the,mind. The evolutionary psychology of emotions and behavior martie g.
The evolutionary genetics of personalityy lars penke1,2, jaap j. Science, religion, and naturalism plantinga, alvin on. In 1993, alvin plantinga published the first two books of his eventual trilogy on. Alvin plantinga where the conflict really lies science. The book examines where this conflict is supposed to existevolution, evolutionary psychology, analysis of scripture, scientific study of religionas well as. What are the best books about evolutionary psychology. As a nontrained neophyte in the world of philosophy, i found this book very rewarding in putting some context to plantingas work. Plantingas evolutionary argument against naturalism the. Evolutionary psychology approach mark van vugt1,2 and allen e. Plantingas overall theme in the book is that there is a superficial conflict.
1557 1314 818 1554 369 601 128 38 85 1140 162 1540 423 1419 779 916 1601 696 1154 531 679 609 744 379 653 1309 157 390 1123 312 1065 1051 52 691